..it is not okay..

2008 August 4
by a.lenore

**disclaimer: this is a borderline rant, which I try to keep from doing as much as possible here, so bear with me.**

***This post is brought to you by last night’s dinner conversation with Vernon and Aubrey***

So, I have this list. It isn’t a hard copy or anything, just a theoretical/spoken list of things that I have observed while living in Israel that are not okay. I’ve been talking about it and adding to it a lot this year. The things that make the list don’t necessarily have to do with Israel or the Middle East at all, although many things about life here do make the list and go straight to the top. For example, some orthodox Jewish men study Talmud all day and don’t work while their baby-making machines (read: wives) are at home with several children, trying to run a good household and sometimes have to take a paid job in order to support their families even more because their husbands don’t get paid to read the Talmud all day. If the husband ends up having to get a job because his wife can’t handle the load it’s her fault and is a disgrace. THAT IS NOT OKAY.

Something has been not okay for a long time, and I have neglected to write about it until now. I am writing about it now, publicly, because I no longer think that I need to stay silent. There is this story that I’ve been hearing from several different people over the last few years. They talk about their experience in and with church leadership. They are all different people with eerily similar stories of power-mongering through half-truths and deceptions. They involve scathing emails, threatening phone calls and restraining orders (I wish I was joking). They are stories of how pastors and elders manipulate their way to complete power over a congregation, and then “beat the sheep”, at least the ones that know too much and show themselves to be a threat to the empire.

A common thread in all these stories that I’ve heard is that eventually a pastor will work himself or herself, by whatever means, into a position where he or she essentially becomes the dictator of the local church. This doesn’t happen by force, but rather by the slow abdication of the congregation’s responsibility to hold their leaders accountable. People have become so accustom to consuming church rather than participating in it that they give up their active role as a part of the Body of Christ, thus opening themselves up to all sorts of religious abuses. They begin to rely on the pastor for everything: the interpretation of scripture, what time to meet on Sunday, what the “vision” of the church is, who is able to serve or not serve in a specific role. The church does not belong to the pastor. A local church is not pastor so-and-so’s church. The church belongs to Christ. And when the body of Christ is being mislead, abused or manipulated it is the responsibility of its members to call into accountability those who have been given the responsibility of leadership.

There’s this myth flying around that Christians are supposed to be nice. “The fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, gentleness and self-control.” Nope, nice isn’t in that list. The Bible places a high priority on speaking truth in love. In many instances speaking truth is incompatible with being nice (even if it is in love). One only has to read the prophets to find that out. Jesus did some turning over of tables which I’m certain didn’t get him the “nice-guy of the year” award. What I’m trying to get at is this: it is not okay for church leaders to power-monger and then lord it over people. It is not okay for them to live as though the local church is their own little empire within an empire to do with as they see fit. It is certainly not okay for local church members to stand by and watch other parts of the body be abused by such behavior because they are afraid that people might think they aren’t nice Christians.

And it is not okay that all of this is so common.

**I realize that there is a lot left unsaid here. There are no suggestions made on how to handle specific situations. This is just a general observation and response. I’m more than willing to go back and forth about things in the comment sections.

5 Responses leave one →
  1. 2008 August 9
    Lisa Bowman permalink

    Amen, sister Adria.. Hearts continue to break and hurt over harm that is done in the church system. I find it alarming and unfortunate to say the least. Yet- we move on to a new place into which He has called us.. leaving the past behind and moving toward a new hope. I just never imagined the system could be so very harmful. I love you and agree with your comments.

  2. 2009 March 28

    In a Lay Ministry class on Developing Theological Perspectives (United Methodist Theological perspectives, specifically) a few weeks ago, we talked about the idea of hierarchy vs. authority. I think that our brokenness as humans relates directly to our contortion of the idea of authority. We want authority because we use that language to talk about control and power, where Jesus used that language to talk about the authority to act on behalf of the Father – in other words – I have the authority to serve anyone I please and can do it in any way that meets their needs. I am granted that authority by God Himself. If you are a teacher of religious law who has abused authority by refusing to serve, then I have the authority to not submit to your brand of authority. That is freedom through submission to God, not slavery through submission to pastors. When we submit to authority that is not based in service that is born of love, then we sacrifice our uniqueness in the Body of Christ. As you pointed out, this happens gradually. When clergy would give up their clothing to don a black or white cloth, they would give a visual representation of their submission. When they adorn those cloaks and cloths with gold and velvet and symbols of hierarchy, then we begin to lose that impact of that symbol, and we are responsible for pointing that out. In fact, I think that we are entitled to make a great stink about it.
    Rant it may be, my dear old friend, but appropriate and timely it is. Did that just sound like Yoda? Great to dive into your thoughts once in a while – please keep them coming.

  3. 2009 March 28
    a.lenore permalink

    Awesome, Bryan. Thanks for bringing that perspective. We often perceive clergy donning robes as authority and not the apparel of servants. I think we have been against such things because we misunderstand or haven’t been informed of the meaning behind it. I love the Methodists. It’s true. Thanks for commenting. Would love to see you and your family sometime…it would be glorious.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. ..The Shack: a review (pt. 2) « sea of adria
  2. Shepherds, Humility, and the Back of the Bus « EIKON Israel

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS